Any redhead does not Lucy make. We know Kidman, no one new? And Bardem's Desi - needless to say, is completely miscast, for like,100 reasons, including his AGE. Like West Side Story, Hollywood miscasts a classic. Nina - Vivian - is adored (Richard Jewell), though she's young. But it's Fred and writer Madalyn who give the movie any credibility. Only Hollywood thinks it makes sense to produce a fake documentary doubling down on 2 sets of completely miscast characters, younger AND older. Had they just cast the leads well and let them all do their thing on this well documented history, we'd be in classics heaven. We actually see little great show moments and near none of Desi's musicality. FYI, Ball IS incredible in The Big Street - a true revelation. However, she'll always be comedy genius.