After I received this fil, I pulled out the original (Rex Harrison) and watched it. You know, see them in order. OMG! What was I thinking? While I realize they are very different types of movie, I had forgotten that ANY resembalence to the two is purely coincidental!!!
Further more, the original is awful. Bad songs, bad puppets, bad script! While I will never get rid of the original (I have very fond memories from childhood (where I apparently chose seriously bad cinema) or my tastes have changed drastically! I think it may be a bit of both. Here's my advice...get both. The old one is considered a classic, and kids adore it. I think that's enough reason. As for the Eddie Murphy version, get it. It is a funny and magical ride.