I had ordered a smaller bag of these to ensure my horses enjoyed them and they did! They loved them! I opened this large (much more expensive bag) and the treats were dry, powdery and my horses wouldn’t even try one. A huge waste of money, very disappointed I will not buy the smaller bags either as I am afraid of getting rotten treats. The worst is I can’t exchange them or return them “this product tidbit eligible for return.” Ridiculous.