They were as hard as rocks and I'm not kidding. So hard, I was afraid his teelth would have broken off if he tried to bite into one of them. i got a little angry, in fact that I was sent a product that had turned into stones. I tried to cut into one of them and knife wouldn't even saw it's way through..sending them back would be too much trouble and time that is not well spent..so i got cheated out of my money and they were not cheap. They are labeled "Good n Tasty", not "Good n Fun" package is identical, however.