Top critical review
Decent, pretty waterproof, but it smudges!
Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on January 8, 2021
First I would like to say that the price is very good. I bought this eyeliner because I was running out of my current eyeliner and needed one ASAP and I wanted to try a pencil eyeliner (since I mostly use liquid ones).
Upon arrival everything was excellent, the pigment is very black and nice, but I’ve been using it for a month now and I have a few things to say.
It applies nicely, gives me the ability to line very close to my lashes giving them a fuller look, which is what I love about pencil eyeliners vs liquid.
It was pretty waterproof, had to use makeup remover to get rid of it since water wasn’t cutting it.
However, the true down fall is that it smudges. If you let it it dry a little it’s a bit more smudge proof (at least when tester on my hand which is the thick lightly smudged test in the picture) but I have noticed that it gets under my eyes. giving them a dark look after a while maybe after 8 hours (funny thing is I don’t apply it to my lower lash line!). If I am careful to avoid smudging, it lasts all day.
I will say decent liner if you’re on a money crunch, it’s definitely usable, but the smudging really got to me. I’m constantly checking under my eyes for any smudging/transfer. As a daily eyeliner user, it’s not very convenient.
Overall 3.5, not the worst eyeliner, it applies really well, easy to use, but not the best. I’m still on the hunt for the “perfect eyeliner”!