Top positive review
Use this every day
Reviewed in the United States 🇺🇸 on August 28, 2022
This is a really great eyeliner. If you're looking for a very durable dark brown gel liner, I would absolutely recommend it - I've been using it for years. One of the only eyeliners or shadows that doesn't transfer to my upper lid, *and* it's fairly easy to take off when you want to remove it. Just water will not work, but I generally remove it with a cloth or in the shower with a small amount of sweet almond oil. It stays all day, unless I rub the outside of my eyes more than a small amount (and that's on me - the only eyeliner I've found that will resist that is MAC liquidlast liner, and that takes some doing to remove and is more of a crisp liquid line). I wouldn't say it would last through a night of sleeping on your side, but it does exactly what I'd want an every day long-lasting liner to do.
The only reasons I did 4 starts, and not 5:
Grey is more of a light taupe, and brown is quite close to black (I use brown, so I do like it, it's just not as light as it looks on the packaging). Also, I have not had any success at all using the blending end or even my own brushes, so this is not a smokey liner for me in any sense of the word. The line is fairly crisp, just shy of a liquid liner. So if you're looking for a shadow stick to smudge on your lid, I would not recommend this.