Amazon.com: Customer reviews: Earth Rated Dog Poop Bag Holder with Dog Poop Bags, Durable and Guaranteed Leakproof, Lavender Scented, 1 Dispenser and 15 Bags

Reviewed in the United States on January 31, 2019

Size: 2 Dispensers, 900 BagsColor: UnscentedVerified Purchase

Months ago, I spent probably longer than a normal person would researching poop bags on Amazon. I ended up ordering the Earth Rated bags based on reviews and was not disappointed. I have now repurchased multiple times, and am glad they have a larger box. I get the unscented because I personally feel that lavender scented dog poop still smells like dog poop, but whatever floats your boat.

They are well made, thick material. I’ve never had one rip on me. Large enough to fit large dog poops.

Attached is a picture of my dog because I doubt you would want to see the bags in use. Plus he is cute and the world should see him.

405 people found this helpful

Helpful

andrzej raczynski

So close to perfection.

Reviewed in the United States on February 11, 2018

Size: 1 Dispenser, 15 BagsColor: Lavender-ScentedVerified Purchase

I bought this specifically because of the design of the mechanism that attaches to the leash, i.e. the velcro strap and the recessed slot it goes through on the body. Most of these devices use a simple little loop on the outside of the body, which has a tendency to eventually break. There's no way that this will happen here. So 5 stars on the design of that. However, for whatever reason, they decided to only include one 'spike' for the roll of bags to sit on. So once the roll is in and the thing is closed, it has a tendency to not sit centered while you pull out a bag and will tilt to one side and rub against either the spike (bad angle) or the bag against the body of the device, which makes it rather hard to pull out a single bag without also sticking your finger in the hole to push the roll away from the opening so as to somewhat recenter it while pulling. That part of the design is just plain stupid, so gets 0 stars.

It either needs a second matching spike (from the other half of the device), or the first one needs to be twice as long.

Not sure why they skipped the second spike, as it would have made it the absolute perfect bag dispenser.

I might just snap out the piece that's there and replace it with a long solid screw or metal rod of some kind. Properly anchored in place it should take care of the problem.

199 people found this helpful

Helpful

Brad Backman

A whole lotta bags for picking up s***

Reviewed in the United States on January 23, 2020

Size: 1 Dispenser, 900 BagsColor: Lavender-ScentedVerified Purchase

My wife was like, why did you buy 900 poop bags for our dog? I was like, do the math! He goes once in the morning, once at lunch time, and twice at night. That's 4 times a day for 365 days, that doesn't even get us close to a full year. For the record, I had to do the math on a calculator...I actually just did and 4x365=1465. So this purchase will get us to about August 12th. So yea! I bought 900 bags, and you know something? I don't have to worry about buying another batch of these until this summer! so am I thrilled about that? You betcha! This kit also comes with spare containers that clip on the leash, this is perfect as we have two sets of leashes. One for around the yard(short) and one for hikes and long walks(retractable) So now we don't have to fumble around when we switch leashes like some kind of psycho. The scent of the bags is nice, but once you put dookie in it, well it's kinda like walking into a Yankee Candle Store. You're like is this a bad smell? is it good smell? Kinda...it kinda is...but no...ultimately no it is not. Does it mask the pooh smell, to a degree. You gotta tie that sucker off ASAP, son! The bags themselves are sturdy, I have yet to smash my fingers into a pile of turd... yet! There's always a first time for everything. The one cool aspect as there's a little sticker tab that allows you to place the dung bag into the container, close it, and then extract the bag so that you now have a rolodex of nameless crap bags. The one thing that I question is, why not make a box full of 1500 bags? and maybe they do, I will check after this. But 1500 would cover the whole year and then some. I don't anticipate this dog ever not having a BM. I suppose not every dog is built the same. Some dogs maybe only take 2 giant stools a day. Some smaller dogs maybe 15-20? who's the say? No dog is equal and we shouldn't treat them that way, nor should we treat their bowels the same either. Would I buy this product again? Uh yea! I have to in about 8 months...

88 people found this helpful

Helpful

Bad Wolf

A Must Have For Pet Owners

Reviewed in the United States on April 19, 2019

Size: 1 Dispenser, 30 BagsColor: UnscentedVerified Purchase

All pet owners should have one of these poop bag dispensers. This particular unit holds large rolls of any brand and has a small hook that makes transporting “used bags” so simple! The manufacturer provides two rolls of “biodegradeable” poop bags with this dispenser and the dispenser easily attaches to any lead with the provided strip of hook/loop fabric - the fabric on this hook/loop strip tends to fray over time and I ended up using a conventional key ring to attach it to my dog’s lead handle. Overall, this is an excellent poop bag dispenser made with durable/rugged material that can be tossed/thrown/stepped on/etc and it will be just fine. Replacing empty rolls is as easy as unscrewing the bottom half and inserting the new roll. I have no complaints about this item. Simple, rugged, secure, convenient!

Once you’ve used the hook, you’ll understand how valuable and useful it really is. So if you’re in the market, give this make/model a try and I’m confident you’ll be pleased with your purchase.

I most definitely recommend this particular pet poop bag dispenser. My 8 year old greyhound has one of these dispensers on each of his everyday leads.

100 people found this helpful

Helpful

Mark Montminy

Works great, I need a few more.

Reviewed in the United States on June 29, 2016

Size: 1 Dispenser, 15 BagsColor: Lavender-ScentedVerified Purchase

Over the years I've tried about a dozen different bag holders. I've got some cheapo-freebies that come with the bags, I've bought some fancy nylon/velcro ones, plastic ones, rubber ones.. none seem to work well, or last. The caps pop off, the bag roll falls out, or they jamb up and don't dispense a bag well. They all seem to suck.

I got fed up with the ones we have, and figured I'd take another look and see if someone came up with a better bag holder. This one was very highly rated, and not very expensive.

I see why it's rated so high, it-just-works. It's a 2 piece screw together design, so no end caps to fall off, or get pulled off when pulling a bag through. The side opening is generous enough to allow the bags to come out, but not so big they fall out.

There's a good sized spindle inside to help hold the rolls and keep them turning while dispensing. I've tried a few different rolls of bags in it from different brands, and they've all worked just fine.

It only comes with a small bag roll, which is fine, I wanted it for the dispenser, not the bags. However, the included bags were also quite good.

120 people found this helpful

Helpful

Donald Coleman

Holds a lot of sh*t

Reviewed in the United States on June 30, 2019

Size: 2 Dispensers, 900 BagsColor: UnscentedVerified Purchase

I have two medium to large dogs and if you have dogs then you know what that means. Fortunately my girls are good and they take care of business in our backyard. Downside is that my kid plays in my backyard, so we “bring in the harvest” almost daily.

These do the trick and you get to keep your hands clean, unless you don’t want to and please keep that to yourself. My only gripe would be that they can’t completely stop the smell. Fortunately I don’t sit around drinking beer and admiring the girl’s work, so that isn’t much of an immediate problem. But I feel for my trash man, my garbage can smells like a used diaper in the summer.

58 people found this helpful

Helpful

Kim

Hands free and loving it.

Reviewed in the United States on May 14, 2020

Size: 1 Dispenser, 30 BagsColor: Lavender-ScentedVerified Purchase

Tired of loosing bags and carring the full ones? So was I. Then we bought this little gem. Perfect? No, but affordable and holds the empties and the full bags leaving me hands free. Just ordered another for the other dogs leash. Win win.

(Not having the issues some others noted getting empties out of the container).

60 people found this helpful

Helpful

James Dailey

biodegradable whether you use or not

Reviewed in the United States on October 7, 2017

Size: 1 Dispenser, 900 BagsColor: Lavender-ScentedVerified Purchase

I purchased these bags 2 years ago. I liked the biodegradable in 2 years selling point. I just did not realize that must have meant I only have less than 2 years to use 900 bags. I have 45 rolls of bags left that fall apart in my hands when I try to unroll them. I store them inside my home. They were great until now. Very disappointed.

40 people found this helpful

Helpful

ANB

If you are buying poop bags...

Reviewed in the United States on November 18, 2012

Size: 1 Dispenser, 900 BagsColor: Lavender-ScentedVerified Purchase

For years I had been using the ubiquitous Bags On Board poop bags feeling good about myself for using "biodegradable" bags. Turns out that theirs are only biodegradable in the sense that eventually the earth will melt down and nothing will exist anymore but, you know, semantics. After doing some more research, I came across the Canadian Earth Rated brand. Perfection. They even have a cardboard core. If you care at all about your ecological footprint/your dogs pawprint, then I highly recommend these. I immediately ordered them up along with their fantastic holder, which, ingeniously has a hook built onto it allow you to clip used bags onto it for the rest of the walk. Little feature, but very very smart. I don't miss those blue bags one bit.

Yes this is certainly a first world concern but if you have a dog, and if he/she poops AND if you clean said poop up with bags, you should make them these. And while you're ordering them, you might as well get them in bulk unless you have some sort of fancy dog who eventually phases out defecating altogether.

Canada - you are officially forgiven for Bryan Adams!

473 people found this helpful

Helpful

Maria

Why fix something that aint broke?

Reviewed in the United States on October 11, 2019

Size: 1 Dispenser, 15 BagsColor: Lavender-ScentedVerified Purchase

I am very disappointed with this new design of the dispenser.
I had the old one for years, until the bottom half came loose and got lost, so I decided to buy it again. To my disappointment so may things were wrong with this new design that I had to just throw it away and buy something that resembles the old design more, alas from a different brand.
1. They got rid of the plastic loop on the top and replaced it with useless velcro-ish material. It didn't feel secure enough to connect to the leash and was a weird scratchy texture, so I threw it out and replaced with a zip tie which I connected to an aluminum carbine from the old dispenser.
2. They removed one of the pins inside that was holding the bag roll in place. Which resulted in increased difficulty when taking bags out. Since they no longer rotate freely, the whole roll comes loose, and the bag gets stuck when you try to pull it out. A small frustration, but gets annoying when you have to do it at least twice a day.
3. Most annoying thing - they added a clip to one half of the dispenser. I don't know where it's supposed to clip to, as nowhere on the leash seems secure or convenient. Instead, when you screw the bottom part on or off to replace the bags you have to watch your fingers, because this thing slams into them painfully.
In other words, this is a huge step down from the original design, and was money wasted.
I still use the bags, nothing wrong with them so far, thankfully.

10 people found this helpful

Helpful

5 star		86%
4 star		9%
3 star		3%
2 star		1%
1 star		1%

Earth Rated Dog Poop Bag Holder with Dog Poop Bags, Durable and...

›

Customer reviews

Customer reviews

Earth Rated Dog Poop Bag Holder with Dog Poop Bags, Durable and Guaranteed Leakproof, Lavender Scented, 1 Dispenser and 15 Bags

Top positive review

Top critical review

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

From the United States

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

Questions? Get fast answers from reviewers

Earth Rated Dog Poop Bag Holder with Dog Poop Bags, Durable and... › Customer reviews

Customer reviews

Earth Rated Dog Poop Bag Holder with Dog Poop Bags, Durable and Guaranteed Leakproof, Lavender Scented, 1 Dispenser and 15 Bags

Top positive review

Top critical review

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

From the United States

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

There was a problem loading comments right now. Please try again later.

Questions? Get fast answers from reviewers

Earth Rated Dog Poop Bag Holder with Dog Poop Bags, Durable and...

›

Customer reviews